Did Tea Party populism accomplish anything laudable? Or should we see it exclusively as a cautionary tale?
The story clearly has elements of tragedy. Or hypocrisy. It was a movement ostensibly committed to limited government, obsessed with recovering the dignity of being a free people. They donned colonial costumes and did public readings of the Constitution and Thomas Paine. Yet somehow, it morphed practically overnight into an authoritarian populism that would feel depressingly normal in Latin America. Officials who thundered from on high about the debt crisis, and even provoked a dramatic standoff with the Obama Administration over a 14.3 trillion dollar national debt, went on to cheerfully help Donald Trump add trillions more. (In case anyone’s still counting, it just hit 40 trillion.) They called themselves “libertarian populists,” but eventually jettisoned “libertarian” for “populist.”
Here’s another quick explanation for what happened: In the Reagan years, people used to talk about “the three-legged stool,” which combined moral traditionalism (the Judeo-Christian piece), a strong foreign policy (a descendant of anti-communism), and limited government (classical liberalism). It was a pretty balanced platform. The Iraq war undermined the foreign policy leg, while the same-sex marriage fight left the moral traditionalists reeling. We were left with a one-legged stool, and what happens if you try to sit on a one-legged stool?
I’ll get back to criticism shortly, and yet, I must also acknowledge: The Tea Party had its virtues. It was unstable, and there is indeed something quite strange about a populist push for fiscal austerity and constitutionalism, so perhaps it’s unsurprising that “Don’t tread on me” for many bled quickly into, “because I would prefer to tread on you.” But they got a lot of things right. I am not sorry that I stepped into the conservative conversation at that particular moment.
Perhaps I should pause here and explain how that happened. It’s quite odd really; in the Tea Party days I was rubbing shoulders with small government populists, critiquing many of their libertarian premises, and then the tables turned and many of them shrugged off those premises, while I ended up working for Liberty Fund. Life is full of surprises.
Part of the story here is that I was way more interested in philosophy than politics in my youth. I met Bill Clinton once as a delegate of Girls Nation, and I have a fun memory of traipsing around the Mall after midnight on the eve of my Peace Corps departure (“I’m shipping off to Uzbekistan tomorrow, Mr. Lincoln!”), but those were my main youthful experiences of Washington. So in 2012, I was mostly a stay-at-home mom with a baby, a toddler, a third on the way, striving heroically to be domestic, but also poor and intellectually frustrated. My life options were pretty constrained under the circumstances, but my husband was a regular listener of the Ricochet podcast, and he suggested that I might find an outlet on that site.
Ricochet worked like this: there was a public-facing “contributor” page with posts from recognizable people, but anyone could become a member by paying a small monthly fee. Members could post whenever they wanted on the private member board, and the editors would move certain posts to the public-facing page. Each week on the main podcast they would highlight a “Member Post of the Week,” and the author would get a free Ricochet coffee mug. I got off to an encouraging start! I won the mug with my first post. It still sits on my desk, full of pens.
Don’t get the wrong idea, though. I wrote some dumb and clueless things on Ricochet, got properly schooled, and upped my game. I was learning the logic of limited government, which was genuinely a fun new challenge for a trained Aristotelian. Once I had spent my days thinking about habituation; now I was walking around thinking about infantilization. I was coming to appreciate how the modern state, by assuming all sorts of functions that were once filled by communities, families, and private institutions (such as churches), had caused those “muscles” to atrophy, pushing these other institutions to the margins. And as people become further infantilized, they tend to demand still more state intervention.
Once you see it, you can’t unsee it. I found myself reading Rand now (who didn’t impress me much) and Hayek (who did), and thinking about how to juxtapose these ideas against the Aristotelian ones that had been so formative for me. I backed into fusionism, just by encountering the relevant influences in sequence.
Elderly entitlements were the ultimate sticking point of course, and one could say with some justice that Republican voters were open to limited government only so long as it was someone else’s benefits on the chopping block. It’s worth noting though that the really burning issue of the day wasn’t welfare but Obamacare. Healthcare concerns everyone. And the debate over a single-payer system really cut to the heart of the issues.
I was already aware that Europeans mostly considered it barbaric that the United States did not have single-payer healthcare. Why don’t we care about sick people here? We do, actually. We spend a fortune on our health. But health, as I came to appreciate, is a very personal thing, literally and figuratively. What does it do to us, morally or psychologically, when we entrust our very persons to the tender care of the state? Do we want the state to hand us a band-aid whenever we bleed?
I still find it impressive, and in many ways hopeful, that a message like that could still resonate on the right as recently as 2015. But clearly, it didn’t last. Why not?
First and most obviously, the Tea Party never really figured out how to govern. They learned to get elected but they did trend towards “party of no,” and though there were a few people like Paul Ryan who clearly cared about policy, they couldn’t get sufficient traction, and when chances at real reform opened the Tea Party Republicans mostly shuffled their feet, bickered among themselves, and punted. That’s pretty damning.
It’s not entirely surprising though to someone who was part of the discourse. Which did frankly get a little absurd. Admittedly it’s not fair to judge whole movements based on the cranks you remember from the internet, and yet, I doremember the tone of those conversations, and that’s revealing in certain ways. They leaned pretty hard into the Randian individualism, which makes it hard to think broadly about what politics is, or what human societies, communities, or even families actually do or require.
I have a funny memory from my days on The Federalist writer’s board in which I tried to provoke a discussion of “what, if anything, can government rightly do” by suggesting that surely it was at least okay to, say, maintain Arlington Cemetery on the public dime? Surely, I argued, we can use public dollars at least to cut the grass around the graves of our fallen warriors?
I got piled on. A whole lot of people insisted it was not okay.
When the postliberals talk about “market fundamentalists,” my inclination is to be dismissive. I will acknowledge, though that there was some of that in the Tea Party era. A narrow-minded fixation on small businesses and entrepreneurship. A refusal to discuss hard questions because, “Markets magically solve all the problems so we don’t need to.”
Classical liberalism has some valuable resources, but it’s not the only tool we need. The narrowness of Tea Party populism left the right vulnerable to less-admirable populist strains, and the lesson for conservatives now is that that paradigm needs to be combined with others.
I’m writing all this from sunny Savannah, where I’m attending the first-ever meeting of the Anti-Federalist Society… err… our Law & Liberty conference on the Articles of Confederation. It’s quite a treat, actually: as one of the publication’s editors, I get to be the least-qualified person to sit around a conference table with political theorists and historians, discussing late-18th-century political documents and the early American conversation about what self-governance requires. (There’s nothing to lament in being the least-informed person at the table! Pay attention and you’ll surely learn something.)
It’s quite relevant actually to my theme here at Christendom Reborn. The late 18th century represents a moment in history when some fairly powerful forces (war, daunting debts, general chaos) were pushing the United States towards centralization and consolidation, and yet, a sizable contingent of people were still eager to push back. And the result was… well? That’s a question, isn’t it? What is the legacy of antifederalism and efforts to restrain the state? Is it always a lost cause?
Maybe I’ll get a chance to say more about that soon. For now I better stop writing and go finish the conference. Have a great weekend, all.




Ricochet was kinda fun!
I remember Ricochet! Heady days.