Discussion about this post

User's avatar
bill walsh's avatar

The problem I have with paganism is not so much at the individual level where natural virtues and the Christianized context of Western Civilization generally just make it sort of a personality test, for good or ill. The real problems with it that I see (drawing mostly on its history in the west) emerge at scale, creating the airless, fatalist, cruel societies we see in ancient literatures (or modern attempts to take them seriously on their own terms—more Eggers’s Northman than Nolan’s Odyssey)

Nathan Smith's avatar

Well, I'd say now he mixes a sociobiologically informed view of human nature, dismissive of feminism, with classical liberal political preferences. It's not a complete conversion because he doesn't think he was completely wrong. The point is that when you're arguing with someone like Bronze Age Pervert, you are, as you say, arguing in part with a kind of performance art, written to draw clicks more than to be intellectually cogent, and to draw clicks partly through shock. But the clickbait does appeal partly through addressing flaws in a modern politically correct/woke worldview. Hanania springboarded to fame and effectiveness through the internet's dark side, then repented, in a suitably partial way; he's still fiercely anti-woke. He's the intellectually serious version of your "monsters." He's the one to tackle.

4 more comments...

Ready for more?