6 Comments
User's avatar
bill walsh's avatar

The problem I have with paganism is not so much at the individual level where natural virtues and the Christianized context of Western Civilization generally just make it sort of a personality test, for good or ill. The real problems with it that I see (drawing mostly on its history in the west) emerge at scale, creating the airless, fatalist, cruel societies we see in ancient literatures (or modern attempts to take them seriously on their own terms—more Eggers’s Northman than Nolan’s Odyssey)

Nathan Smith's avatar

Well, I'd say now he mixes a sociobiologically informed view of human nature, dismissive of feminism, with classical liberal political preferences. It's not a complete conversion because he doesn't think he was completely wrong. The point is that when you're arguing with someone like Bronze Age Pervert, you are, as you say, arguing in part with a kind of performance art, written to draw clicks more than to be intellectually cogent, and to draw clicks partly through shock. But the clickbait does appeal partly through addressing flaws in a modern politically correct/woke worldview. Hanania springboarded to fame and effectiveness through the internet's dark side, then repented, in a suitably partial way; he's still fiercely anti-woke. He's the intellectually serious version of your "monsters." He's the one to tackle.

Rachel Lu's avatar

I don’t know that he wants to banish the strictures of a love-centric universe though. So not really “the one to tackle” for the purposes of that post. Even if he doesn’t endorse the foundations he still supports the architecture to a considerable extent, thus does not illustrate nearly as well my point about the consequences of rejecting love.

I’m not saying that he’s not worth tackling though. Complicated cases can be good and I still of course think his perspective is very reductive and thus prone to all sorts of errors. That would be a different sort of project, but one I might take on sometime, and certainly if he ever wants to mix it up with me I’m game. (We’ve had friendly conversations a couple of times though I don’t know him well.)

Nathan Smith's avatar

Good point. Utilitarians are Christian-derivative; so are rights-oriented deontologists. I agree that you have to go pretty far in an ugly direction to really get out from under the moral penumbra of Christianity. Hanania is surely a lot more Christian than Marcus Aurelius.

Nathan Smith's avatar

So I kind of like this, in an "it's a dirty job but someone's got to do it way." These aren't writers that I've ever been allured by, or really, that I've ever read.

But at some level, I think you've picked too easy targets, and I want to ask: What about Richard Hanania? He's the most ruthless critic of right-wing clickbait, but he basically buys into a post-Christian worldview based on nature as rooted in evolutionary psychology. How does this essay look if it's re-targeted on Richard Hanania?

Rachel Lu's avatar

Hanania had an awful phase (the ugly kind of revanchism), as he himself admits. He sees himself as saved by liberalism, in a sense, and I think he did realize that a lot of what he endorsed before was not just ugly, hateful etc but also wrong on sort of an empirical level. Good for him for acknowledging that, if he did. How deep does Hanania's "conversion" go though, and how trustworthy is it? Hard to say.

There are lots of less-serious reductive positions and postures out there, which can still be pretty objectionable without falling all the way to this level. But the extremes make the point more clear.