Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Nathan Smith's avatar

And obviously obedience is not infantilization and isn't at all incompatible with moral maturation or rationality. Nor is there any tension between a "casting vote" and spousal companionship and friendship. Why would there be?

Nathan Smith's avatar

So this all kind of leaves me banging my head against a wall. Logic, people! Logic!

Yes, male headship in the sense of a casting vote is likely not to fit your day-to-day experience. Hopefully you don't have fundamental, unsettleable disagreements all that often. Maybe you've never had one. If you're similar, you've have it relatively easy, and you're good at talking things through, then talking it over and coming to a consensus decision may have been enough. But what if there's a decision you really need to make, and no matter how much you talk and pray about it, you still just don't agree? If you want a marriage to be reliably permanent, there needs to be an answer to that.

"People work cooperatively all the time without a casting vote." Yes, but these egalitarian collaborations also break up all the time. Coauthors. Bands. Business deals. Fine; they don't need to be permanent. Marriage does.

And anyway, stability and operational efficiency in human organizations usually require hierarchy, even when permanence is much less morally important than in marriage. In companies, for example. Mere bilateral, non-hierarchical arrangements between firms are less stable in business than corporations.

I could give examples from real marriages, but it's tricky because that has to be private. "There was this time when Mr. X and Mrs. X disagreed, and Mr. X finally just had to say... And they lived happily ever after..." Well, the details that would make that compelling are the details I can't share on a public thread. Still less "Mr. X and Mrs. X had a profound disagreement, and she just did what she wanted, and it harmed or ended the marriage."

"Despotic" is a straw man. I mean, yes, a husband shouldn't exercise authority *despotically.* Who advocates that? Maybe some in angry reactionary corners of the web. "As to the Lord" actually might suggest something like that, but never mind, I won't explore for the moment. The "casting vote" is the very minimum you might draw from the example of a wife submitting to her husband as to the Lord.

Male headship isn't Lewis's invention. He's faithfully arguing for what has been the Christian tradition from the beginning. To discuss marriage while deliberately leaving that out, using a straw man attack on "despotism" to suggest that it isn't there, is an oddly gerrymandered Christianity, making it safe for feminism in a way that actual Christianity just isn't. Advanced degrees for women aren't specifically forbidden, but it's a problem if a wife wants to get an advanced degree that her husband doesn't think serves the family's interests and she insists on her way. It might be a problem if she insists on using an advanced degree professionally when the family's interests are better served by her staying home with the kids.

"Christianity is no threat to the hard-won autonomy and equality of women" is a false advertisement. And feminism's likely culpability in the disastrous decline of modern marital permanence needs to be wrestled with.

10 more comments...

Ready for more?