12 Comments
User's avatar
Nathan Smith's avatar

And obviously obedience is not infantilization and isn't at all incompatible with moral maturation or rationality. Nor is there any tension between a "casting vote" and spousal companionship and friendship. Why would there be?

Nathan Smith's avatar

So this all kind of leaves me banging my head against a wall. Logic, people! Logic!

Yes, male headship in the sense of a casting vote is likely not to fit your day-to-day experience. Hopefully you don't have fundamental, unsettleable disagreements all that often. Maybe you've never had one. If you're similar, you've have it relatively easy, and you're good at talking things through, then talking it over and coming to a consensus decision may have been enough. But what if there's a decision you really need to make, and no matter how much you talk and pray about it, you still just don't agree? If you want a marriage to be reliably permanent, there needs to be an answer to that.

"People work cooperatively all the time without a casting vote." Yes, but these egalitarian collaborations also break up all the time. Coauthors. Bands. Business deals. Fine; they don't need to be permanent. Marriage does.

And anyway, stability and operational efficiency in human organizations usually require hierarchy, even when permanence is much less morally important than in marriage. In companies, for example. Mere bilateral, non-hierarchical arrangements between firms are less stable in business than corporations.

I could give examples from real marriages, but it's tricky because that has to be private. "There was this time when Mr. X and Mrs. X disagreed, and Mr. X finally just had to say... And they lived happily ever after..." Well, the details that would make that compelling are the details I can't share on a public thread. Still less "Mr. X and Mrs. X had a profound disagreement, and she just did what she wanted, and it harmed or ended the marriage."

"Despotic" is a straw man. I mean, yes, a husband shouldn't exercise authority *despotically.* Who advocates that? Maybe some in angry reactionary corners of the web. "As to the Lord" actually might suggest something like that, but never mind, I won't explore for the moment. The "casting vote" is the very minimum you might draw from the example of a wife submitting to her husband as to the Lord.

Male headship isn't Lewis's invention. He's faithfully arguing for what has been the Christian tradition from the beginning. To discuss marriage while deliberately leaving that out, using a straw man attack on "despotism" to suggest that it isn't there, is an oddly gerrymandered Christianity, making it safe for feminism in a way that actual Christianity just isn't. Advanced degrees for women aren't specifically forbidden, but it's a problem if a wife wants to get an advanced degree that her husband doesn't think serves the family's interests and she insists on her way. It might be a problem if she insists on using an advanced degree professionally when the family's interests are better served by her staying home with the kids.

"Christianity is no threat to the hard-won autonomy and equality of women" is a false advertisement. And feminism's likely culpability in the disastrous decline of modern marital permanence needs to be wrestled with.

Nathan Smith's avatar

Re: "The Church isn’t continually trying to browbeat women into submitting to their husbands’ despotic authority."

"Wives, submit to your own husbands, as to the Lord. For the husband is head of the wife, as also Christ is head of the church; and He is the Savior of the body. Therefore, just as the church is subject to Christ, so let the wives be to their own husbands in everything." (Ephesians 5:22ff)

And the rationale for the rule is very straightforward. If marriage is to be permanent, the couple needs to have a way to make decisions. But you can't have a democracy of two. You get one versus one, an unbreakable tie anytime there is a disagreement. So there has to be a casting vote. Husbands are urged to love and sacrifice themselves for their wives, as Christ did for the Church. He shouldn't be a despot, obviously, and he shouldn't rule the marriage in his own interest. But he is called to be the head of the family, to lead, to make the decisions.

So argues John Chrysostom. So argue CS Lewis.

If one applies this rather basic decision theory marriage, one might expect that a rejection by the culture of male headship would lead to a collapse of the permanence of marriage. That fits the facts.

"We" find this repugnant in the modern West. Count me out of that "we."

Rachel Lu's avatar

"Despotic" is a key word here, and there are articulations of male authority and headship that I can get behind, but I've never found Lewis' arguments on this point very compelling. It just doesn't describe reality as I experience it; people work cooperatively all the time without a "casting vote." And I think that dynamic is pretty deeply in tension with spousal companionship and friendship, which clearly modern people also desire.

I've always found the "as to the Lord" part of that passage interesting too. God doesn't exercise despotic authority over us either. Does God "make the decisions" in *your* life? How often have you been in a debate with God and said, "OK, I guess you get the casting vote?" That's not how I relate to the Lord. He doesn't infantilize us by regularly cutting off our own deliberation with cut-and-dried commands.

There is a disparity of authority assumed here but "not slavish or despotic in character" seems to me to be clearly built into it. We submit to the Lord out of love, accepting his guidance precisely as a gift of love, but in ways that never need undercut our own rationality or moral maturation. I definitely think there's something real here, worth pondering and trying to live (which I do) but I don't think it properly cashes out in husbands "making the decisions" or having "casting votes."

And really, the kind of speculation you get on this in the more reactionary corners of the internet (which may mirror reactionary subcultures also?) is pretty abhorrent. Who would marry those men? They want to reduce women to permanent infancy, so they can enjoy the reassurance of total control.

Nathan Smith's avatar

Re: "Mind you, I’m not positing some simple or direct causal relationship, far less suggesting that we could restore a healthy marriage culture by rolling back a SCOTUS decision. Forcing a re-litigation of that issue, right now and in our present climate, would be a spectacularly bad idea."

Why?!?!

For one thing, a right to same-sex marriage obviously isn't in the Constitution, so Obergefell is obviously a lie. It's not okay to condone lying even if you did think reopening the case would lead to civil war or something.

But the flagrant attack on democracy represented by that disgraceful case is absolutely an ongoing cause of our civic crisis, and it strikes me as more than a little nuts to think that the maintenance of this anti-democratic judicial coup d'etat is somehow helpful to the political climate.

Down with Obergefell! ASAP! Duh!

Andrew's avatar

One thing to note about the push for same sex civil marriage is that it represented a triumph within the gay rights movement by a faction that wanted to normalize goods like monogamy and family formation within the gay community. Gay civil marriages, at least between men, have a lower divorce rate than heterosexual marriages. All of this is to say that the legalization of same sex civil marriage probably did some positive work in strengthening commited, family friendly unions in society. Divorce rates as a whole have also stabalized.

What has changed over the past 10 years has been the growing ubiquity of porn, pot, opiods, online gambling and short form video that has made a large chunk of the male population incapable of attracting a wife and building a successful marriage. The modern crisis of coupling and low fertility seems to be mostly a smartphone problem.

Rachel Lu's avatar

From what I've read, roughly 10% of gay and lesbian individuals are civilly married to a person of the same sex, and something like 20% of those are raising children. It doesn't look to me like this community has in fact embraced "monogamy and family formation" with much gusto, certainly not enough to stabilize heterosexual marriage. But we're talking about a smallish minority of the population anyway and really... my honest view is that it doesn't greatly matter what they do *from the standpoint of bolstering heterosexual marriage.* It matters for their own good, but really, the choices of same sex couples probably won't ultimately impact heterosexual marriage that much one way or the other.

But I do think the movement and cause had an effect. Precisely because it impressed itself so deeply on the minds of that youthful generation. Insofar as their takeaway was "bourgeois stability and long-term companionship are a great good that need not be connected to children..." I'm pretty meh on that. I mean, one could do worse, but sterile bourgeois life doesn't clearly seem to me like some awesome good that we should bend over backwards to champion.

Andrew's avatar

Thank you for the thoughtful reply, Rachel.

First, a small statistical clarification. Gallup's most recent figures show that about 19% of gay and lesbian adults are married to a same-sex spouse. The figure for "LGBTQ+" adults overall is just 8%, largely because that broader category includes bisexual people and transgender people.

But the larger point I was trying to make is about the history of the gay marriage movement itself.

For decades, there was an internal debate within the gay community about whether marriage was an institution worth embracing. Some viewed it as an outdated, patriarchal institution that gay people should have no interest in replicating. Others, including the gay Catholic writer Andrew Sullivan, argued that lifelong, monogamous commitment was a genuine good and that gay couples should be encouraged to pursue it.

That latter vision became an important part of the movement for civil marriage rights. Whatever else one thinks about same-sex civil marriage, I find it difficult to see a movement that encouraged people to embrace fidelity, permanence, and family formation as a major contributor to the decline of marriage. I agree with you that its direct effect on heterosexual marriage was probably quite small, but I think its cultural influence was at least partly positive.

Where I agree with your article is that we've lost a shared understanding of what marriage is fundamentally for. But I'd locate that transformation much earlier, particularly in the middle decades of the 20th century, when marriage increasingly came to be understood as a romantic partnership centered on personal fulfillment rather than a permanent institution ordered toward family formation.

This cultural transformation was accompanied by major legal changes, particularly the liberalization of divorce laws. Many of those reforms were responses to legitimate problems, including people being trapped in marriages marked by abuse, infidelity, or addiction. But combined with the loosening of sexual norms, they also had unintended consequences: rising divorce rates, more births outside marriage, and eventually the near-collapse of marriage in some lower-income communities.

My sense, though, is that the last 20 years have seen a kind of stabilization of this newer understanding of marriage. Divorce rates have fallen substantially, in part because people are marrying later and because marriage itself has become increasingly concentrated among the people most likely to sustain it.

Which brings me to what I think is the more immediate problem.

I suspect today's crisis of coupling and fertility has less to do with further changes in our understanding of marriage and more to do with the conditions that make people capable of pursuing it in the first place.

In particular, I put the blame on the effects of the smartphone era, including ubiquitous pornography, online gambling, short-form entertainment, and other easily accessible forms of instant gratification. Add problems like drug addiction and economic instability, and you have a substantial number of young men who are increasingly disconnected from the habits, responsibilities, and relationships that would make them attractive marriage partners.

I don't think technology explains everything, but I suspect it's a much more important contributor to our present difficulties than the legalization of same-sex civil marriage.

Put another way, I think the great transformation in what people think marriage is for happened decades ago. The more recent crisis is that an increasing number of people seem unable to build the kind of life that makes marriage possible, even when they sincerely want it.

Rachel Lu's avatar

Thanks for the statistical correction. And I certainly agree that all the things you mention (smartphones, pornography, other forms of instant gratification) are important contributing factors to the problem. I do not at all want to advance some sweeping multi-causal story blaming the marriage movement for our present troubles.

But as you'll note, I think the connection of marriage and childbearing is pretty vital to making marriage into a meaningful and life-guiding institution, particularly for the non-rich. A sort of comfortable, slightly aristocratic "companionship" model works okay for the very well off. It doesn't work for the bottom 40%. And marriage has absolutely collapsed there. Divorce rates have fallen partly because that entire demographic has largely stopped getting married.

Even for the well-off, it often doesn't work. Without childbearing as a central component, the path to finding an adequate spouse and situation is pretty narrow even for the privileged. And many of them are likewise ending up alone.

Again though, I don't think this has very much to do with what same-sex couples are or are not doing. Their lifestyles aren't that causally consequential wrt heterosexual marriage, but the movement, the decision to make *marriage* into a "right" and a core platform for exploring personal identity... yes, I think that was harmful.

Obviously this would all be quite hard to prove one way or another.

Andrew's avatar

Thank you for the thoughtful reply, Rachel! I suspect our differences on same-sex civil marriage are real but relatively minor.

I think we're in agreement about the collapse of marriage among lower-income Americans. It's a real problem. Where I differ, assuming I understand you correct, is in what I see as the most immediate obstacle to reversing it.

I agree that the shift toward a companionship model of marriage is part of the explanation. But I'd locate that transformation 80 years ago, with changing divorce laws, the sexual revolution, declining religious participation, and women's increasing economic independence. The implications of those changes have gradually worked their way through society.

So my first disagreement with you is that I'm not convinced that anything in recent decades has actually changed how most people look at marriage, which has been seen since the 1950's primarily as a love contract.

What has changed are the rational calculations of young women whose dating pool consists mostly of men in the bottom 40% economically. I don't think restoring an emphasis on the procreative purpose of marriage necessarily addresses the problems she faces.

If marriage is fundamentally about forming a family and raising children, then surely one of her most important considerations is whether a prospective husband is capable of being a dependable father!

Obviously low income is not synonymous with poor character. But economic insecurity, less religion, social isolation, pornography, gambling, and other forms of instant gratification can make an already difficult situation worse. The smartphone has amplified those problems, and countervailing institutions that once helped form young men for adult responsibilities have weakened considerably (it's been a while since we've had a world war).

If a woman concludes that a guy is unlikely to remain faithful, shoulder responsibilities, or put the needs of a family ahead of his own desires, I can understand her reluctance to marry him. She might still have sex with him, but why would she want to make a lifelong commitment to someone she doesn't trust to be a dependable husband and father?

So my second disagreement is that it seems like taking the procreative purpose of marriage more seriously would seem to make that calculation even more important.

So even if we could somehow persuade people that marriage is fundamentally ordered toward having and raising children, I worry we'd still leave the central problem unaddressed, which has to do with the question of what most people think the good life is.

I know you think and write a lot about that, and as a Catholic myself I largely agree with many of your proposed ideas on that front!

Thanks for taking the time to write all these thoughtful pieces.