12 Comments
User's avatar
Lane Scott's avatar

I live in a rural place and grow some things and keep some animals, and I've known a lot of Wendell Berry acolytes. The standout feature is an enthusiasm and willingness to *think* a lot about working, about people who work, about what work *means*.

I've never met one who was good at working, certainly not manual work. I've never met one for whom hard labor came naturally. Talking comes naturally. Talking while other people work.

That's sort of the whole problem with Berry's deal: he imagines himself to understand laborers or farmers best because he thinks and writes about them. But I know some people who knew him in real life, and their reports of his ethic/ways were not flattering. He wasn't seen as a farmer or hard worker by some of the actual farmers who knew him, anyway.

Is that a crime? No, but I find it borderline unforgivable for a writer and intellectual to fake it as a manual laborer, to never master that 6am-6pm work-outside-all-day way of life, and then have the audacity to make a fortune telling other people that they should be doing that which he never could, or would.

But again, as I said above, my experience with Berry followers is that they are not really farmers or laborers, they are mostly people who like to talk about the good of manual labor while watching others do it, or living far away from those who do it.

Rachel Lu's avatar

Amen, Lane. So much better just to acknowledge “we’re different kinds of people, and I can respect you without trying to be you.”

Chet19's avatar

I loved this essay when I first read it 27 years ago, not because I thought Berry was right in his conclusions, but because I was an exercise in considering wether or not to adopt a particular technology. Our culture has reflexively accepted every new invention without any consideration of the repercussions. I don’t know, maybe we shouldn’t give a smartphone to a 10 year old.

Nathan Smith's avatar

I'm as anti-Luddite as anyone, but I think righteous nostalgia has its uses. Just about every age has morally declined from a well-remembered past in some respect or other, and "Why can't you be as X as your grandfathers were??!!!" has a perennial persuasiveness.

But it shouldn't be an excuse to dodge the duty of critical thinking. On the contrary, it's just when "the past is not like the present" becomes a spur to critical thinking that righteous nostalgia can start to become valuable.

Mary C. Tillotson's avatar

Thanks for spelling all this out. I haven't read any of his work but I've read a lot of essays by people familiar with his work. While generally I don't love the unthinking acceptance of more tech for the sake of tech (our Township hall recently replaced the sliding black letters sign with a screen, which I'm sure is more expensive, and instead of instantly seeing the upcoming meeting date, I have to wait for the "follow the billing dept on Facebook" and other nonsense to pass by before I see the upcoming meeting date, and all this while I'm driving - what is the advantage here?), I've had some unease about his ideas as well, and I think you put your finger on them.

Lee Oser's avatar

Excellent.

Giuseppe Scalas's avatar

lol I don’t think that poor Wendell Berry’s relationship with his wife was mediated by a typewriter. He’s just saying that a word processor would have robbed them of their time spent together. After all, to disintermediate human relations is the nature of a good deal of recent technology. I wouldn’t underrate the fact that voluntary human relationships often mean no relationships at all. The data about technology-induced anomie are already staggering, and the human price paid, huge. It takes a particular kind of human to thrive in voluntary associations. A lot of people, in a world of pure choice, won’t be educated by the necessity to confront themselves with the image of Christ and will be lost, as many already are today.

Rachel Lu's avatar

Look man, I'm just reading what he said. And the reality is that he was giving her a massive job, and she was *already his wife*. How can you really parse this to *not* imply that he thinks her gratuitous performance of this extremely laborious task is somehow necessary to maintain the quality of their marital relationship? Are you saying that they... were not the kind of humans who "thrive in voluntary associations"? Wendell Berry and his wife?

Giuseppe Scalas's avatar

It might well be the case that having this little 'cottage industry' they shared was important to them, even if not strictly necessary.

Marriage is actually an interesting case. To Catholics, it is freely chosen but not freely left, making it a place to hone one's capacity to see Christ in one's spouse, even when one finds the other annoying. But I’m more curious about what do you think about my point about anomie. I completely agree with you when you say that a well-ordered community follows purpose. On the other hand, it’s not clear where such purpose comes from. One of the roles of communities is giving people a purpose they can’t find for themselves, so, in a way, community precedes purpose. As you yourself say “I appreciate that this view has a built-in vulnerability: it demands purpose instead of supplying it”.

If we don’t consider this, we’ll witness an even greater divide between the strong communitarians, building purposeful communities, the strong self-sufficient individualists, and the weak being left to drown in a sea of anomie.

The nature of Christendom used to be such that people, even the weakest ones, weren’t never left to their own devices in the path to find their purpose, at the beginning even against their recalcitrant will.

I think that this names a problem for the libertarian Catholic to be sorted out (the libertarian Calvinist, on the other hand, would be just fine)

Merina Smith's avatar

I haven’t read Berry’s work, but can tell there is an ivory tower element to it. I respect and appreciate thinkers, but many might be inclined to overrate the value of their thoughts and underrate the people who do the work that allows them the luxury of living their thinking life. In Berry’s case, he romanticized the life he was unwilling to live. On some level he seems to have thought it was his wife’s privilege to type up his Great Thoughts that eschewed technology that would have made her life easier, just as machines make farm life easier and more productive. I have read that his son is a farmer. I wonder if he owns a tractor.

Liberty & Order's avatar

I am disappointed I went to bed early and missed the argument. I would have joined in, for sure!

Rachel Lu's avatar

I wish you had! It was a fun nightcap debate!