I had a wonderful time in Savannah this last weekend, eating fresh oysters, strolling under moss-draped live oaks, and walking meditatively among the Confederate graves in Bonaventure Cemetery. Also, there was the actual conference, which was an extended conversation about America’s earliest years, and the political conversations that took place against the backdrop of myriad challenges: war debts, rebellions, chaotic disputes over the treatment of loyalists. Wild times!
Then there was the hotel-bar argument about Wendell Berry. More on that soon.
The group included some robust anti-federalist sympathizers. It was quite interesting to engage them, though I still view Hamilton, Madison, and Washington with immense respect. I think in the end they had to win, and yet, I grant that the anti-federalists had their insights and left their mark on our constitutional system. It’s good to live in a country that kicked off with such an intense conversation about freedom.
Now for our intense conversation, the Liberty Fund version of a Saturday-night barfight. It connected in interesting ways with my presently-running theme here at Christendom Reborn, so I’m going to write about it as a lead-in to my forthcoming essay on libertarian pronatalism.
My thoughts are all revolving here around a core set of questions: What loves and attachments should most define our lives? How should we go about forming and ordering them? What is the proper relationship between our politics, and our familial and communal attachments? These were huge questions for Americans in the founding period, and for us today.
Ultimately, I’m steering towards an argument for a revitalized conservatism that is less brutally individualistic than the Tea Party, and less “collectivist” than Trumpian populism. I think we very much need a politics of freedom, but one focused on what Yuval Levin calls “the middle layers” of society: our communities, our families, our churches. The things we build and do together.
But I’m still not a fan of Wendell Berry.
This tends to confuse his devoted admirers, which I understand. They speculate that I must have some psychological hang-up about rural life or the social roles of women, or perhaps just a philistine-like unwillingness to forgive a man his political and ecclesiological mistakes. I ought to like him. We have so many overlapping concerns.
I’m not arguing that Berry’s work has no value, and I can’t pretend to have read more than a fraction of it. I think nevertheless that my core critique is reasonably serious: he was a man who put second-order commitments first. Aggressively first. He made community into a kind of religion, which then defined his other views on every subject: economics, politics, faith. I don’t think that’s the way to build healthy communities. Nor thriving families. Berry’s righteous nostalgia looks to me like a recipe for social dysfunction.
The conversation Saturday night returned several times to what is probably his single most famous essay (from 1987):“Why I Am Not Going to Buy a Computer.” Many people love it. I did not. Actually, my reaction was a little stronger than that, as one of my interlocutors pointed out. “Wow,” he said, at one point in our exchange, “You really hated that essay, didn’t you?”
I guess I did. Yes. Perhaps it’s worth unpacking the reasons.
Berry explains that he does not wish to have a computer because he “doesn’t admire the computer manufacturers.” Also, he is offended by strip-mined coal, which harms the environment, and he feels that he would be “implicated in the rape” in using an electronic device. He is willing to reconsider this position only when “somebody has used a computer to write work that is demonstrably better than Dante’s.” Also there is a personal reason: his wife types his hand-written work on a typewriter, and this is a vital point of connection with “my critic, my closest reader, my fellow worker.”
That last bit ran him afoul of feminists, who were offended by his willingness to deputize his wife as a typist. And it does seem like Tanya Berry was asked to shoulder rather a lot, typing that immense corpus on a 1950s Royal typewriter. Did she really want to, or was she humoring him? That is not, however, the core of my critique. Berry does clearly explain that his wife is not just his typist, but also effectively his editor, and far be it from me to disparage the noble work of editors. If typing his handwritten notes is part of their process, fine. I must acknowledge though that I laughed out loud when Berry asserted that if he used a word processor:
what would be superseded would be not only something, but somebody. In order to be technologically up-to-date as a writer, I would have to sacrifice an association that I am dependent upon and that I treasure.
I understand that it would be quite churlish to read this as an admission that Berry would have “sacrificed” his marriage if someone had stolen his typewriter. I’m sure he wouldn’t. Still, he was able to write that sentence without a trace of mirth, and he is in fact telling us that his relationship to his wife is deeply mediated through a typewriter. And… we’re meant to take this as an example of how he is not alienated by technology?
Let’s move on, though. What truly rankles about this essay is that it feels like Berry’s smarmy attempt to virtue-signal his way out of an obvious tension in his life commitments. He wrote many, many novels, poems, and essays praising traditional farming life, railing against tractors, combines, and chemical sprays—technologies that made farming easier and more efficient. He depicts these primarily as facilitators of money and greed. Traditional rural life was his ideal, and accordingly, he cheerfully sold the grind of hard manual labor as a blessing, filling his novels with upstart youngsters who were lured away to the city, a choice he presents as shallow and misguided.
But he was a professional writer. With an elite education, dedicated fans, and a full and rich creative life. These are real goods, which obviously brought him joy because he kept writing all the way into his 90s. Not many people historically have had that kind of privilege. Quite a lot more people can do it today, thanks to growing prosperity. But there won’t be much space for that kind of thing in hardworking farming communities, especially the kind that refuse to use tractors.
So that’s a loss, a real loss, that would follow from Berry’s recommended choices. I am not per se calling him a hypocrite; there can be reasons for recommending a lifestyle to others without choosing it for oneself. And of course he did farm, a little, though not enough to support himself. But the fact remains that he was blessed with a rich creative life, while explicitly condemning the developments that could make those same blessings available to others. I think it’s reasonable at least to expect such a person to be aware of his remarkable privilege, grateful for it, and perhaps a bit circumspect about the trade-offs of technological advance. Instead he brags about his unwillingness to “rape the earth” by turning on a computer.
And it is a brag. He’s showing that, fancy-credentialed writer though he be, he’s still a true kindred spirit of the slaving tobacco farmer. Not some Greenwich Village dandy but the conscientious, non-alienated kind of writer. Part of a working team. Making writing into a physical task. Rural farmers, I Am One of You.
Sure. Totally persuasive.
Look, I see my writing life as a gift, something precious. I’ve worked hard for it, fought for it, made real sacrifices for it (starting with sleep). That’s not a complaint! Good things cost something. I’m grateful to have that life, and grateful for loved ones who have facilitated it (my husband especially). But a writer-mom of five has to be ruthlessly practical and efficient. She can’t afford demanding habits, fastidious moral qualms, a “writing routine” that the entire household must hold sacred. Find a way to get it done.
To see a man like Berry write about writing in such a thoroughly entitled way, with no apparent recognition of his immense blessings… is a little galling. He can’t step back from his communitarian vision even enough to get perspective on his own life.
I don’t see righteous nostalgia as a healthy foundation for a household or community. It is by nature both rigid and romanticized, ill-equipped to respond to changing circumstance. We should build our “middle layers” on foundations of freedom, and on deeper loves and commitments than the community itself. I’ll apply that philosophy to families in my next essay.
In the meantime, if you like (or are concerned about) college football… feel free to read my essay on principles for reforming it, up at Law & Liberty today. It’s a little nostalgic. But hopefully not too righteous about it.




I live in a rural place and grow some things and keep some animals, and I've known a lot of Wendell Berry acolytes. The standout feature is an enthusiasm and willingness to *think* a lot about working, about people who work, about what work *means*.
I've never met one who was good at working, certainly not manual work. I've never met one for whom hard labor came naturally. Talking comes naturally. Talking while other people work.
That's sort of the whole problem with Berry's deal: he imagines himself to understand laborers or farmers best because he thinks and writes about them. But I know some people who knew him in real life, and their reports of his ethic/ways were not flattering. He wasn't seen as a farmer or hard worker by some of the actual farmers who knew him, anyway.
Is that a crime? No, but I find it borderline unforgivable for a writer and intellectual to fake it as a manual laborer, to never master that 6am-6pm work-outside-all-day way of life, and then have the audacity to make a fortune telling other people that they should be doing that which he never could, or would.
But again, as I said above, my experience with Berry followers is that they are not really farmers or laborers, they are mostly people who like to talk about the good of manual labor while watching others do it, or living far away from those who do it.
I loved this essay when I first read it 27 years ago, not because I thought Berry was right in his conclusions, but because I was an exercise in considering wether or not to adopt a particular technology. Our culture has reflexively accepted every new invention without any consideration of the repercussions. I don’t know, maybe we shouldn’t give a smartphone to a 10 year old.